Lighting

Discussing my experiences with various lighting products, including the new LED bulbs that I am using to replace my camping lights.

The High Pressure Sodium Light: Ubiquitous, effective, but good?

Ever wonder why street lights are orange? For such a fast-paced world technology-wise, it seems somewhat odd that we are still using such a strange color of light for outdoor lighting. Well it turns out it is still a pretty good light source, though with limited use and perhaps a not-so-obvious flaw.

The LED’s Challenge to High Pressure Sodium – YouTube

This is a very interesting video about street lighting.

It turns out humans (and most animals) have a lot of trouble seeing yellow light after dark, which means that much of supposed efficiency of high pressure sodium lights is wasted. Colder light colors, like that of the mostly obsolete mercury vapor lights of 1950s and 1960s, and modern LED bulb are better at lighting up a street with less actual light output. As the video notes, is some evidence today they made a mistake in 1970s ripping out mercury vapors lights in favor of the more "higher laboratory light output per watt" high pressure sodium.

LEDs can be made any color you want based on the phosphorous. Cold white is popular because you can use a dimmer light while it appears brighter to human and animal eyes. Warm white is less disruptive to sleep and wildlife, more pleasant to the eye, and with less light pollution (in theory) but it's harder humans to see. One interesting idea proposed in the video would be to have street lights start out at a lower-output cold white color in the early evening, and switch to a higher-output warm white color in the early hours of the morning, when fewer people are in the street but you don't to disrupt sleep as much.

Another interesting idea from the comments in the video would be to use high pressure lamps (or warm white LED bulbs) in residential neighborhoods, while using well aimed cold white LED in commercial areas, on highways, and other "high crash areas" such as city centers where there many pedestrians crossing the streets. Mixing warm white and cold white strategically could work to further warn drivers -- suddenly transitioning from a warm white color to cold white color could warn the driver that they are entering a "high crash area" and to use extra care proceeding through that area.